Facebook 2-phase login but the access tokens are different for each login?

Solar2D General Questions/Discussion
#1

I am using 2-phase Facebook login without problem in most of time, however recently I am running into a weird situation…

First login “facebook.login( fb_id, facebookListener_phase1)” and I print out the access token in the callback:

facebookListener\_phase1 -\> succesfully logged in, access\_token = CAAWGygmDMewBAE6zIfliZBtUoZA1bcM7ceq5uYXsHvkP5CxnWpkqMXRxBdVmuFWcZC736MnHnltUiILO0VWtOKzcRrCl19n0pO3k8mU0Xq5r9cxyB4ex5BGHkk0B2OmXUqERyvcZC5rKjQTVZBr1eOqxo9sjclww3qmj6qNCTROiZCMFjuZCQGV2hVrTUW26G8j9MpZCqIXD79sgerQZBfoWs

And inside the phase 1 listener, I call the second login “acebook.login( fb_id, facebookListener, { “publish_actions” })” and I also print out the access token in the callback:

facebookListener -\> succesfully logged in, access\_token = CAAWGygmDMewBAE35A9eAvTDizEZB6ZClWZCknHPNwrIIpmg19CJjlUcfhS1PUxyIL0o39DAOG3o1C5q0KZCAGG2wFqmbJ6wZAEvCAyZBKUBYDBjgZCbdNqZCzQRFJunXgZCpFe4piBuTFW9UyTIIZA3fYodXl59GDzzFFECZA7ZA5BTTVxIURn4qsU1X9pMAZAOps9pRYkucb9KpCZC4SaUZAZBiunCZA3FEo73snRaZCQ5LnHklD9nRuBdxWExk2X

These two access tokens are different!

 

They are supposed to be the same. I have tried to logout / remove app in the FB account setting, etc. to make sure it’s like a clean first login but I still see the same issue that the access tokens in two logins are different.

 

Any idea?

 

 

 

#2

Sorry, my bad, they don’t need to be the same. 

I just tested again with an account that works, they are different.

However, I do see another problem.

After the first login succeeds and then I call the 2nd login… in successful scenario, the screen will switch to FB app again to ask for “publich_actions” permission, however for one of my account, it does not show that screen but report error immediately

“(#200) The user hasn’t authorized the application to perform this action”

In the FB backend, I check the permission status, there is no POST permission for my app.

I deleted the app and retry, there is still no chance for me to grant the permission (public_actions) when it’s supposed to be there after the 2nd login is called.

Anyone can shed some light?

Thanks.

#3

Yes, now you have to submit your app to facebook and have it approved in order to have some permissions like the publish_actions.

#4

I think the Facebook approval is to post without requesting permission?

Even I don’t have Facebook approval, my app can still ask for posting permission for one of my Facebook accounts and it works without problem.

Only one of my Facebook & some of my users have such a problem that the the permission request screen (called by 2nd facebook.login()) doesn’t appear.

#5

Sorry, my bad, they don’t need to be the same. 

I just tested again with an account that works, they are different.

However, I do see another problem.

After the first login succeeds and then I call the 2nd login… in successful scenario, the screen will switch to FB app again to ask for “publich_actions” permission, however for one of my account, it does not show that screen but report error immediately

“(#200) The user hasn’t authorized the application to perform this action”

In the FB backend, I check the permission status, there is no POST permission for my app.

I deleted the app and retry, there is still no chance for me to grant the permission (public_actions) when it’s supposed to be there after the 2nd login is called.

Anyone can shed some light?

Thanks.

#6

Yes, now you have to submit your app to facebook and have it approved in order to have some permissions like the publish_actions.

#7

I think the Facebook approval is to post without requesting permission?

Even I don’t have Facebook approval, my app can still ask for posting permission for one of my Facebook accounts and it works without problem.

Only one of my Facebook & some of my users have such a problem that the the permission request screen (called by 2nd facebook.login()) doesn’t appear.