I really think Trainyard was a 1 in 10,000 event. His game is also not an arcade game. Pure puzzle apps need less flash which his is a 100% puzzler. Yours is an arcade game all the way. Arcade games need flash (ie: BeJeweled) IMHO.
Trainyard was flat for weeks/months until it took off in Italy due to a big name app reviewer there “discovering” it from what I heard/read. Then Apple took notice and featured in on the front page in the US. The rest is history. He was lucky in many ways but his app was still VERY polished and simple and set up for success if notice was given.
I think your concept is excellent. Its simple yet challenging and unique in a way. But unless you get lucky…you have to play to your crowd…and from what I have seen…arcade gamers want a lot of “pinball” style flash. The successful apps have a lot of sparkle and glitz and have a bit more pace to them.
I’m not saying you should redesign the game at all…just suggesting a bit more polishing and depth to it. Its the 8-15 year olds that drive the game market…especially in the arcade market. Adults have more money…but they spread it around more. The kids all gravitate to the same stuff. They have a mindset that you have to dial in on and hopefully tap into.
Its very tough to do. We haven’t figured it out either yet. But from what I can tell…its there…you just have to find the pulse of it and once you do…look out.
It seems as though endless play games are losing steam. The successful games coming out now have more depth and gamers are tiring of the endless play style games. I may be wrong…but that is what it seems to be. Yours is an endless game…but there may be room to expand on it and develop a couple of alternate game modes to it.
All in all its a balance. How much time to you dedicate to one title versus starting a new title? I honestly believe that if an app doesn’t take off within 30-45 days…its DOA and its best to move on to the next one. To wait and anticipate a delayed success seems like a long shot to me. I’d rather start a new title than beat a dead horse. [import]uid: 9492 topic_id: 8342 reply_id: 31054[/import]